The recent move by the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency to receive a delay in the assessment process for the Pacific NorthWest LNG project provided for a few moments of reflection at City Council on Monday evening.
"It was quite interesting that many people jumped the gun on the CEAA Report on LNG it was a draft report and asked for people to respond to it, the response is in and the CEAA has deferred a decision for another ninety days. Because the questions weren't asked, so when the Chamber and people in town are saying that it's OK and safe for fish they should read the latest report by the Department of Fisheries and by the CEAA and find out that it's not exactly safe for fish. I just wanted to make sure that people understood that it really needs to be a science debate and not a debate on how many truckers can line up in Prince George and Fort St. John, but really what the impacts on our community are going to be and what the impacts on the commercial and sport fishery ... So I just wanted to point out that the CEAA has not said that the project is safe for fish and that the Department of Fisheries has not said that the project is safe for fish, and so I think that we need to be aware of that." -- Councillor Joy Thorkelson on the recent delay granted to the assessment process for the pacific NorthWest LNG project
Mayor Brain followed up her short review of the latest developments offering some comments on the City of Prince Rupert's approach to the issue, noting that the City has provided input to the assessment process with the CEAA.
"And just for the public's record, the City of Prince Rupert has submitted a submission to the CEAA process with some science, we have a staff member now, who is in charge of dealing with the EA processes, and is dealing with CEAA on a scientific capacity, so that's been submitted. The City of Prince Rupert has yet to sign an agreement with Pacific NorthWest LNG we are still under negotiations, and so we are following along the process with the CEAA and respecting the process as it is going through it. The next three months there will be a decision will be made and however that happens, at that time, the City will most likely respond from there -- Mayor Lee Brain updating Council and the public on the city's contribution to the LNG Environmental Assessment process.
However if submitted, the city's comments are proving hard to find on the CEAA's website, perhaps tucked away on the site, taking up some corner of the digital archive of the long list of submissions available on the issue.
That way residents of the community can learn more about the City's contribution to the discussion and what science the City has cited as part of that participation.
It's worth noting as well that no public discussion in Council Chamber appears to have been held on the topic of the City's contribution to the CEAA process, leaving residents unaware as to where each Council member may be found on the issue of the Pacific NorthWest LNG project.
You can review the conversation on LNG from Monday night as part of the City's Video Archive page, it starts at the just past the one hour, two minute mark.
Monday's City Council session opened with a public opportunity for residents to provide comment on the Budget Process and while no one stepped forward to offer guidance on the City's financial plan for 2016, when the open microphone opportunity was shifted to other concerns as part of the Committee of the Whole process the line up of speakers started to form.
Concerns related to sports fishing and alternative energy issues provided the bookend for the public comment session, but the bulk of the forty four minutes of public concern was centred on issues related to the west side McKay Street area and the downtown part of the city.
Three participants raised a stream of issues for Council to give consideration about, with the focus mainly on concerns about the spread of drugs in the community and the violence that is related to it, as well as a number of traffic issues throughout the city that made up the bulk of the notes for the attention of Council.
A lot of the discussion involved concerns over how conditions may get worse should LNG development ever move into full swing, one contributor outlined her thoughts on the City's Hays 2.0 vision plan and how the pace of development could change the community and force some to leave it owing to housing and social issues, including family violence, broken families and other concerns that those with limited incomes are struggling with at this time.
Crime was also another concern for some of the participants with worries over drug trafficking in the community and the growing violence that seems associated with that problem, some attention was also directed to incidents that take place in the downtown area.
All of the items that were raised by those in attendance should be of some concern for Council, which has plans for the McKay Street park area but may be a little out of the loop on the issues of concern for the people that actually live in the area surrounding that space. Creating an urban oasis may be a nice idea, but if the residents of the area are fearful for their neighbourhood, it would seem that some of Council's priorities may need to be readdressed.
The issues of crime and traffic issues are items that Council should raise in a public forum with the Officer in Charge of the Prince Rupert Detachment.
In years past, Council would regularly have the RCMP come to a public session of Council and provide an update on issues and take questions from the City's Councillors, those engagements have not taken place for a couple of years now and perhaps this might mark a timely moment to return to that opportunity to connect with city's detachment.
It's a process that takes place in neighbouring communities, Terrace Council regularly reviews Quarterly reports during public council sessions and at times hears presentations from the detachment and offers feedback to the detachment from area residents.
As well, the Terrace Detachment is very engaged in providing constant information to the public, offering a regular update to the public on some of their work in the community, that might be something that Council could request of the local RCMP, providing the community with a regular account of some of the issues that face both local residents and members of the local detachment.
The McKay Street area is surely not the only area of the city where residents have concerns about many of those same issues, the fact that those residents felt the need to bring them to the attention of Council however does suggest that it is an area of the city that the City needs to put some immediate focus on.
You can review the full presentation to Council from the City's You Tube Archive, the concerns from residents can be found at the 13 minute mark.
Despite the opportunity for comment from the public on budget issues and other items of concern, Monday's City Council meeting didn't run too much past the one hour mark, with Council members making quick work of the Regular Agenda in the back half of the evening session.
The meeting opened with a Committee of the Whole Session, which first offered up the opportunity for final comments from the public on the budget, a call for comments which went unanswered, leaving the Mayor to move on to General Concerns from the public, a topic which did as things turned out, generate a significant volume of public comment.
Following the forty four minutes or so of presentations, Council would move on to its short agenda for the night, reviewing the Moresby Park Fuel tank issue, providing a final vote on the Cow Bay Marina pricing and appointing local residents to a number of Boards and Societies.
The evening came to an end with an update on the Housing committee work from the Mayor and a number of items from Council members.
For some background on the evening's scheduled items of note, see the Committee of the Whole Agenda for the night here, the Agenda for the Regular Council session for March 21, 2016 can be reviewed here.
Council also had a Closed Session scheduled for the night.
Further information from our overview and placement in the video archive can be found below, with the permanent record of the minutes added as they are posted to the city website.
In attendance March 21, 2016
Mayor Lee Brain-- Present
Councillor Barry Cunningham-- Present
Councillor Blair Mirau -- Present
Councillor Wade Niesh -- Present
Councillor Nelson Kinney-- Present
Councillor Gurvinder Randhawa-- Present
Councillor Joy Thorkelson -- Present
Video Archive for March 21, 2016
(0:00-44:00) Committee of the Whole -- Mayor Brain, outlined the process ahead for the Committee of the Whole session and then called on the City's Financial Officer to provide a brief review of last weeks Public Forum on the Budget and short presentation related to the Budget process. From there he opened the floor to comments on the Budget from the public, but no one in attendance in the public gallery came forward to speak to that topic.
Moving forward on the Committee of the Whole Agenda the Mayor then asked if any members of the public had comments or concerns for Council, a request which did provide for a number of residents to come forward to outline some concerns on a range of issues.
The first participant was a representative of the local sports fishing charter business, speaking for other members about their concerns over the influx of Alberta based charter operations that were providing competition for local groups without taking out City business licenses and other items that local operators must have. He called for Council to seek better enforcement of the local issues at the local docks.
The Mayor noted that it was the first he had heard of the issue and would be looking into the concerns, he then turned the discussion over to Councillor Thorkelson who noted that she has been trying to address the issue over the last ten years. Reviewing further some of her thoughts on how the City could address the issue. Councillor Cunningham also offered up some potential solutions, which would see the City seeking more enforcement from the province and federal governments for the area.
The Mayor wrapped up that theme by noting that it was time for Council to address the issue and solve some of these issues, adding that he would get back to the resident on this one
The second participant of the General Comments, opened up her comments expressing her concerns over the struggles that many in the region are finding these days in the community. Adding that she has some struggles with the City's Hays 2.0 Vision document, calling attention back to the original Charles Hays vision and its impact on First Nations, while taking a particular focus on the prospect of LNG development in the region that makes up a portion of the Mayor's new vision.
Noting that she has noticed significant change in the community with just the announcement of proposed developments for the region. Calling attention to such issues as violence in the community, suicides and suicide attempts, families that are being broken up, increased drug trafficking and family violence. She provided some anecdotal testimony to a number of local incidents that have been of concern to her reviewing them for Council members. Noting that many residents are starting to leave the community over such issues as affordable housing, renovictions and other issues.
Those themes of crime, housing issues, drug trafficking and downtown violence as well as traffic concerns dominated the majority of the other contributors on the evening, with significant attention focused on the McKay Street area.
On the theme of the plans to remake the park in the McKay Street area, one presentation outlined how there was a need for change to the park that would reflect some of the concerns of those that live in the McKay street area.
Erratic driving and speeding through both the residential areas and throughout the downtown area also made for a few observations as part of the open commentary process. With some concern expressed about the driving habits of local cab drivers.
Concerns over LNG development in the community also made for some of the background to the Open Comment period, with fears over safety issues with the industry and concerns that long time residents may soon need leave over financial pressures related to the speculation in the community.
One final presentation outlined an interest in seeing the City approach alternative energy options as a path to follow, noting that there has been significant attention directed towards LNG and suggesting that the City investigate opportunities with Wind Energy opportunities to accommodate our energy needs.
The Mayor noted that some of his background in University was in Sustainable Community Development and how he was quite familiar with the themes that were raised, he further called attention to the City's recently launched policy group of 2030 Sustainable City, that will explore the vast opportunities available such as wind, tidal, geo-thermal, solar and such.
He outlined how municipalities are financially limited and have to try to find partners, that are interested into getting into those things, and that from all of it's financial concerns it's hard to find a few million extra into say wind. Adding that if they did have that kind of money available, he was sure that council would be willing to do things like that, noting that it was also part of the City's Hays 2.0 plan.
Councillor Cunningham noted that the person appearing in front of Council is the kind of person the City should be seeking to sit on the City's Sustainable group and wondered how he might be able to do that. The Mayor noted that later this year, once the initial policy work is complete the City would be conducting a call out for volunteers to lend assistance to the program.
Following the Presentation the Mayor then directed Council's attention to the Regular Agenda for the evening.
(44:00-45:00) Regular Council Session for Monday, March 21, 2016 -- The Mayor reviewed past minutes and the current agenda for the evening. Councillor Cunningham pointed out an error in one of the accounts under review. ( 46:00 -- 53:00 ) Presentation to Council -- Mr. Robert Grodecki and the City's Operations Manager Richard Pucci on the topic of the Moresby Fuel Tanks -- Council were provided with an overview of issues related to the Fuel Tanks that located in the Moresby Park area, Mr. Pucci outlined the nature of the partnership that the City could form with the Skeena First Nations Stewardship Society which is seeking a letter of support from Council to apply for a grant towards the project. Mr. Grodecki offered up a thumbnail sketch for Council of the work of the Stewardship Society and its interest in the Moresby Park project and what it could contribute towards the remediation work involved. The Mayor noted that this was wonderful news and that if the money can be accessed it would be a welcome addition to the project and how it is time for those tanks to be removed from the park. Councillor Thorkelson inquired as to how much money that could be obtained to put towards the cost of the project, asking further of the Mayor if the project was included as part of the Capital Budget for 2016. The City's CFO noted that it was not put into the Capital Budget for this year, but that there is a fund in place for future use for the project, based on an estimate towards the cost of the project. Councillor Cunningham wondered if there were provincial or federal funding available towards the project, Mr. Pucci outlined some of the approaches that the City has taken on towards that theme, but noted that the City purchased the land on an as is basis which limits its opportunities to access funding, noting that can continue to seek out grant opportunities to minimize the impact on the community.
Reports
(53:00--53:30) Report from the City Operations Manger -- Following up on the presentation, Council then voted to approve the request to provide a letter of support to the Skeena First Nations Stewardship Society.
( 53:00 -- 55:00 ) Resolutions from Closed Council sessions -- The City's Corporate Administrator outlined the list of appointment to different Boards and Societies in the Community, the list included:
Prince Rupert Performing Arts Centre Society --Ms. Joanne Finlay Prince Rupert Airport Authority --Mr. Don Scott, Ms. Gloria Rendell, Mr. Kelly Sawchuck and Mr. Knut Bjorndal Port Edward Historical Society --Ms. Laurie Davie
Bylaws
(55:00-- 55:30 ) Report from the Chief Financial Officer on the Cow Bay Marina Fees and Regulations Bylaw -- Council held a final review of the Cow Bay Marina Fees and Regulations Bylaw and gave it final approval.
( 55:30--1:07:00 ) Reports, Questions and Inquires from Council
The Mayor provided an overview of the latest developments with the Housing Committee. Noting the two streams that the Committee is reviewing adding that the next phase for Council's attention will be a workshop that will be held shortly.
He outlined some notes related to the Draft Report to be sent to the Provincial Government on what kind of services will be needed around affordable housing, noting that Council will soon review that report and then come up with a concept related to affordable housing.
He also how he has joined another committee and outlined his work with on issues related to creating an alcohol and drug rehab centre in the community.
He wrapped up his Housing report by outlining that an approach towards the Provincial and Federal government for funding would be the next level of the project, noting that the Federal government has a 60 Billion dollar fund that it as about to announce and part of it will be about Social Infrastructure. Adding that there is some debate at the Federal level as to whether that money will directed to the provinces or directly to the municipal level, with the Mayor suggesting that the city might have a better chance of accessing some f that funding if it's directed to communities.
Councillor Cunningham asked if the City had heard any more about a bypass road, noting concerns he has about traffic issues in the community. He had a particular concern about truck traffic that is going through town, especially with the work taking place at the yacht club that large trucks are transiting through east side residential areas. He suggested that the City should be contacting the RCMP for increased traffic enforcement.
The Mayor offered up some thoughts on the prospect of a bypass road along Wantage road, advising as to some recent conversations that he had with the Transportation Ministry. He noted that the City had been discussing the topic with the Port Authority and that the Port had noted that they are looking at an alternative plan to construct a road towards the Ridley Island direction. And whatever the solution is it, it should be the right solution for the entire area. Adding that the next step is to build some kind of case for the province, to show the feasibility of any transportation plans.
Councillor Thorkelson offered up some guidance for Council on the issue of traffic through the east side residential areas, noting that it's the designated truck route into the city and that traffic levels tend to rise with the fishing season, adding that there are also weight laod issues involved with the Bridge by Breakers.
She then turned her attention towards developments with LNG issues in the community. Noting for Council the recent decision of the CEAA to extend the environmental process by ninety days. Suggesting that many in the community had "jumped the gun" on the CEAA report on LNG and how the Agency had deferred its decision, adding that the questions weren't asked noting that when the Chamber and people in town are saying that its OK and safe for fish, they should read the latest report and learn that it's not exactly safe for fish. Ms. Thorkelson observed how it needs to be a science debate and not a debate on how many truckers can line up in Prince George and Fort St. John, but what the impacts are going to be on our community and the fishery.
Wrapping up her thoughts, she noted that DFO and the CEAA have not ruled that the project is safe for fish and that's something that people need to be aware of.
The Mayor followed up her points by noting for the record that the City has provided a submission to the CEAA process, with some science provided by a staff member who is in charge of dealing with EA processes and is dealing with the CEAA in a scientific capacity. He also noted that the City has yet to sign an agreement with Pacific NorthWest LNG and is still conducting negotiations, and so are following along with the process with CEAA and respecting the process as it is going through it.
Mayor Brain also outlined that over the next three months a decision will be made and however that happens at that time the City will most likely respond from there.
Councillor Kinney offered up his concerns over the wolf problem in the city, expressing some background over a recent incident on the waterfront in the city. Councillor Cunningham noted that the proper process is to report the engagement with wolves to the Conservation Officers in Terrace who can only act on issues if they are aware of them.
With no more reports from Council, the Mayor brought the regular session to an end, with Council then reconvening their recessed Special Closed Session of the evening.
You can access the City Council Review for March 21 here, where a number of items regarding the council session, including links to media coverage of it can be found.
As always, our Council Timeline is only a reflection of our observations from the Council session of the night. Be sure to consult with the official minutes from the City, when posted to their website for further review.
Official Minutes of the Regular Council Session from March 21st (not available yet)
Council next meets in Regular session on April 11th in Council Chambers at City Hall.
The Federal Government has put the Environmental process for the Pacific NorthWest LNG project on pause for three months
Saturday's announcement of a ninety day extension of the Environmental Assessment period for the Pacific NorthWest LNG project has led to the dispatch of a number of provincial officials to Ottawa to try and lend a helpful hand in moving the process along quickly towards a final decision by the Federal Government.
As we noted on the blog Saturday, the surprising latest twist in the timeline towards a decision on the project was delivered on Saturday afternoon by the CEAA, announcing that the Federal Environment Minister Catherine McKenna had granted their request for the three month extension to the Assessment process.
LNG Minister Rich Coleman took to his twitter feed on Monday to note that Senior officials from British Columbia were working with the Federal government to overcome the delay, with the province still hopeful of a positive final outcome for the much anticipated LNG project proposed for Lelu Island.
Coleman noted the economic impact that the project would have on the province, the job creation opportunities and the nature of some of the consultation that has taken place through the process related to the Pacific NorthWest LNG proposal.
The LNG Minister is not the only one engaged in the LNG file this week.
British Columbia's Finance Minister has been on a tour of Asia during the course of the last week, with stops in India and Malaysia on his agenda for his travels. Included in his plans was meeting with Petronas officials to discuss the province's partnership with the energy company on its B. C. plans.
No updates have been provided as of yet by the Provincial government on those discussions.
The B C Liberal government may have good reason to express its concerns when it comes to any further delays to the approval process.
As the Pacific NorthWest project heads into its ninety day extension, reports coming out of Asia suggest that the window of opportunity may be slowly closing on the province's ambitious plan for development of natural gas resources.
The battle for the 2016 Coy Cup takes place this week in Terrace
The final hockey of the season in the Northwest is taking place this week as the Terrace River Kings host the 2016 Coy Cup.
And while the Prince Rupert Rampage won't be part of this years festivities, North Coast residents perhaps longing for one or two more games before they turn to Spring activities can head east for their fix.
Making their way to the Terrace Sportsplex to take in what should be a fairly competitive five days of Senior Men's hockey.
Four teams are competing in this years event, the CIHL champion Smithers Steelheads, host River Kings,Whitehorse Huskies and Fort St. John Flyers.
The River Kings, who gained a spot in the tournament as the host city, have had the longest break between games, so will be the team with a bit of rust to shake off as they take to the ice as part of tonight's opening matches.
Smithers successfully navigated the CIHL playoff season, first dispatching the Terrace River Kings and then the Williams Lake Mustangs on their way to the CIHL title.
The Fort St. John Flyers head into the week as the team to beat, the defending Coy Champs from 2015 and from accounts in the Northeast they are more than happy with that status. They come to the tournament having dominated the North Peace League through 2015-16.
The Yukon's entry the Whitehorse Huskies secured their spot in the Terrace tournament with two out of three victories in a hard fought series with the Powell River Regals in mid March.
The Huskies had the longest of the bus rides to make it to tournament time in Terrace, heralding their successful arrival in the Northwest of BC with a photo of their first workout prior to the tournament puck drop tonight.
Double headers make up much of the schedule through the first three days of the Tournament. With Friday's Semi-Final match bringing together the second and third place finishers, the winner moving on to challenge the First place finisher on Saturday night for the opportunity to claim the AA Senior Men's trophy for 2016.
The full schedule for the week can be reviewed below:
Tuesday, March 22 Smithers 5 vs Whitehorse 6 Fort St. John 3 vs Terrace 3 (tie game)
Wednesday, March 23 Fort St. John 5 vs Smithers 3 Terrace 6 vs Whitehorse 3
Thursday, March 24 Whitehorse 6 vs Fort St. John 5 Smithers 2 vs Terrace 6
Friday, March 25 Semi Final Whitehorse 3 vs Fort St.John 7
Saturday, March 26 Championship Game Fort St. John Flyers 3 vs Terrace River Kings 2 Fort St. John Flyers are the 2016 Coy Cup Champions
Tickets are available at All Season's Sports or Sonny's Collectibles. Tickets can also be purchased at the Sportsplex during the day and at game time.
We'll update the scores as (if) they become available through the week.
You can learn more about the participating teams below:
Opening Day is but a few weeks away for the latest attraction on the Prince Rupert waterfront, with the public invited down to the waterfront area of the Atlin Terminal on Saturday April 8th to officially open the new Public Dock of the Cow Bay Marina.
The party invitation was issued through the City of Prince Rupert's website on Monday, with Mayor Lee Brain making note of the anticipation for the opening and the access to the waterfront that the new facility offers to the public.
“It’s really excellent to see how much positive attention the public breakwater has received, before it’s even officially opened,” ...“We’re really happy to be able to provide residents with more waterfront access, something that community members have said loud and clear that they want, and a goal that the City has identified in our Official Community Plan.”
The timeline towards the finish line for the project faced a few delays along its path towards completion, the funding and the main momentum for the project finally coming together in 2015.
The main structure started to take shape over the summer and the finishing touches were put in place over the winter by the main construction contractor Broadwater Industries.
Funding for the project came through a range of organizations including from the Western Economic Diversification Fund, Northern Development Initiative Trust, Fisheries Legacy Trust, Community Futures Pacific Northwest, City of Prince Rupert, Prince Rupert and Port Edward Economic Development Corporation, Communica Public Affairs and the Prince Rupert Port Authority.
The April 8th Public Celebration will take place from 11 AM to 2 PM and is free to attend, among some of the plans for the event will be free hot dogs, music and other activities.
You can learn more about the thoughts on the completion of the project from some the other partners from the City's media release.
Spring may just flipped over onto our calendars, but the City of Prince Rupert's recreation department is already thinking of summer, taking applications for staff positions with their Summer camp program.
Each year the City of Prince Rupert hosts popular summer time events for the community, with their Summer Camp program a particular favourite with residents of the North Coast.
The planning for the summer of 2016 is already underway, with the City preparing to start reviewing applications for both a Summer Camp coordinator and staff assistant for the summer program known as the "Big Kid".
Some background on the two employment opportunities can be found below, Applications should be delivered to the Recreation Centre, the Deadline for the two opportunities is fast approaching set for March 24, 2016.
Summer employment opportunity with the City of Prince Rupert As a Summer Camp coordinator
Summer employment opportunity with the City of Prince Rupert As part of the Summer Camp program
You can track current and past labour opportunities with the City of Prince Rupert through our archive page here.
