Friday, March 2, 2018

Some rumblings of discontent from one of the BC NDP's most loyal constituencies

North Coast MLA Jennifer Rice has done much to praise a stream of
NDP policies in recent weeks, however, as we found out this week
City officials would like a little more action from the NDP cabinet
when it comes to some of the area's financial needs


While North Coast MLA Jennifer Rice has just nicely settled into her position as the Parliamentary Secretary for Emergency Planning and the duties that come with it, there might be a need to take a little bit of time to address a couple of issues that seem to be percolating back at the newly relocated home office on Second Avenue West.

An interesting aside in this week's City of Prince Rupert Budget presentation should serve as a warning shot that there's a bit of a disconnect between the MLA and the city council of her hometown.

As part of Monday night's budget notes, Corinne Bomben, the Chief Financial Officer for the City took a political turn on the night and fired a salvo in the direction of Victoria.

With the CFO noting the city's disappointment that the province has yet to address an ongoing issue related to tax caps that the province has in place as part of a incentive program for large industrial proponents.

"The problem has been that the province has placed a limit on the property tax rate that the city can use to collect taxes, Council has tried  for years to make the province aware of the unintended consequence of this legislation. There was hopes that the new government would bring some relief, however it has only been a change of actors and not the story"

That would be the ouch moment for the NDP government, comparing their work to much of the same old, same old, that the city has regularly complained about in the past when it came to the previous Liberal government.

Even worse, particularly for the staff at the MLA's Prince Rupert constituency office, the City is calling on some help from taxpayers of the city, urging residents to send in some letters of concern to their MLA, urging action on the issue

"We encourage you to write your local MLA Jennifer Rice insisting that this provincial incentive program be compensated in total by the province"


Prince Rupert City Council and staff have returned to some frequent
concerns over financial disparities in the region

(photo from City of PR website) 

Another issue that seems to be a lightning rod between the City and the province is the state of affairs between Prince Rupert and Port Edward when it comes to the Ridley Island Tax Sharing Agreement.

The City would like to renegotiate that arrangement, but so far there has not been much enthusiasm from the District of Port Edward towards that idea, and  considering that the District will receive an additional 300,000 dollars this year, making for a total of 900,000 dollars coming their way from Prince Rupert, that probably shouldn't be a surprise.

One imagines, that the City of Prince Rupert might like to have the MLA and the provincial government weigh in with some thoughts and assistance towards their goal of a more balanced distribution of money on that file.

Then there is the Northwest British Columbia Resource Benefits Alliance and that regional desire for action on their much discussed goal of a better sharing of the resource revenue pie in the region.

Last September during the annual trek to the UBCM meetings, the members of the organization were quite enthusiastic about their talks with Premier Horgan and other government officials, with much talk at the time of a belief that the new NDP government had a better understanding of the issues.

“This agreement will also ensure local First Nations benefit as well, by allowing us to strengthen relationships with the surrounding communities ... This will be a win-win for everyone.” -- City of Prince Rupert Mayor Lee Brain

“It’s refreshing to be working with a government that is committed to finding a way to make this agreement happen ... John Horgan also committed to meet again in December to check in on the progress that has been made.”  -- RBA Co Chair and North Coast Regional District Chair Barry Pages

Close to six months later, and with a budget that offered up no indication of any kind of financial payout to come the way of the Northwest, one wonders if the municipal officials are feeling quite as smitten with the new Premier.

For an organization that was quick to the media releases during last years election campaign and in the courting phase of the relationship with the new NDP government, the Northwest Resource Benefits gang have been quite subdued of late when it comes to speaking out on the status of their initiative.

When it comes to updates on how things are going between the NWBCRBA and the government, there have been no new declarations of Peace in Our time to be found since September, from either their website or Facebook page.

Over the course the last few weeks since the MLA's returned to Victoria, the North Coast MLA has had effusive praise for the NDP government's Speech from the Throne, Budget presentation and pretty well any announcement that the ministers on the NDP Government side of the house have made

North Coast MLA's Budget Defence includes Prince Rupert references
Jennifer Rice brings Fishery notes from weekend conference to Legislature discussion
More focus on urgent care, nurse practitioners among notes from MLA Rice's statement to Legislature on NDP plans for Health Care





As can be seen, Ms. Rice has done a spectacular job of representing the Horgan Government to the North Coast, a task she takes on with relish and often by pointing out how the NDP has taken a different path than the Liberals previous.

However judging by the tone of the City's Budget presentation of Monday night, Prince Rupert might like to see her represent her home community and some of its financial concerns with a lot more enthusiasm when it comes to discussions with her boss and Cabinet colleagues.

Many of the city's issues of note from the past are reviewed through our Council Discussion page here.

For more notes of interest on the work of the North Coast MLA see our Legislature archive page

A larger overview of Provincial issues is available from our political blog D'Arcy McGee

To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here

A week of mixed messages on resources from Lax Kw'alaams

The last seven days have provided for a pair of announcements related to a couple of resource issues from the north side of Tuck inlet, and from it all, there appears to be a current of many different views on how the community should explore resource development issues.

That as a court challenge which has now come to an end, as well as plans for an oil shipment pipeline and terminal on the North Coast, all put the community of Lax Kw'alaams in the spotlight for part of this week.

With much in the way of commentary from everyone but the elected council

The week started with a statement from a group of hereditary leaders from the North Coast First Nation, which declared their full support for the federal government's proposed oil tanker ban.

Their comments taking aim at recent statements from Eagle Spirit Energy and its plan for a pipeline and oil terminal project, and Eagle Spirt's intention pursue a court challenge on the legality of the Federal moratorium.

In the Tuesday statement  the hereditary leaders observed that they have never been consulted by Eagle Spirit and have never agreed to support a dangerous project that threatens their indigenous rights and traditional territory.

They further note that along with their support for the oil tanker ban, that Eagle Spirit has never consulted the rightful title holders of Grassy Point, and they have never given permission for the Chief's Council to speak on their behalf.

Lax Kw'alaams hereditary leaders voice support for oil tanker ban
Lax Kw'alaams hereditary leaders reaffirm support for oil tanker ban

The Federal Government introduced their plans for an oil tanker moratorium back in May of 2017.

However, the proponents for the oil terminal for the North Coast took issue with the planned moratorium immediately following the roll out of the plan.

They have continued on with that opposition over the course of the last year, frequently citing a lack of a consultation by the Federal government and the presence of outside funding by environmental groups as part of their approach.

The group recently launched a Go Fund Me page to raise funds to launch a challenge against the Federal Government's moratorium plans.

Eagle Spirit Energy had been making use of a January 24th statement from a group they have described as the Chief's Council to push forward with their momentum for a proposed Oil shipment terminal on the North Coast.

One  potential site for such a type of industrial venture, which has been suggested in the past has been at Grassy Point near Lax Kw'alaams. Most recently it had been identified as a possible location for an LNG terminal.



In early February we took note of the latest notes on that project, with Calvin Helin from Eagle Spirit Energy observing of a Plan B that the energy company has in mind, should their plans in BC not develop as hoped, with a proposal for an Oil shipment terminal near Hyder Alaska.

For its part, the elected Lax Kw'alaams Band Council, led by Mayor John Helin, hasn't had much to say about the ongoing discussion on potential oil terminal development or tanker moratoriums, with no background notes for their community, or those of neighbouring communities, released through any of their information portals of the Band Council website or Facebook page

As this week comes to an end, another resource related  issue had popped back up on the radar, with the Federal Court of Appeal dismissing a case related to the once proposed LNG terminal at Lelu Island.

Donald Wesley, a hereditary leader of the Lax Kw'alaams Nation known as Yahaan had brought the notice of appeal to the court in the fall of 2017, following the announcement of the cancellation of the proposed LNG terminal.

Mr. Wesley who had set up the protest camp on Lelu Island in August of 2015, had launched his appeal las fall with the goal being that the Island would remain free of any possible use related to the LNG industry.

Both his camp and his court challenges appeared to put Mr. Wesley and his group at odds with the elected Band Council in Lax Kw'alaams.

In February of 2017, those officials had signed a number of benefits agreements with the Province of British Columbia and Pacific NorthWest LNG related to the proposed development for Lelu Island.

BC's Liberal Government signs LNG agreements with Lax Kw'alaams and Metlaktla First Nation

LNG benefits Signing Day back in February of 2017
Mayor John Helin represented Lax Kw'alaams at that ceremony

As part of the decision to dismiss the application for a judicial review, the court called Mr. Wesley's quest moot, as the project was no longer moving forward, with no indication that there were any plans for Pacific Northwest LNG/Petronas to reverse that decision.

In a report on the court case, the Globe and Mail's Brent Jang notes that one of the respondents to the appeal court was Lax Kw'alaams Mayor John Helin, who had moved for dismissal for mootness as there was no longer a live dispute between the parties.

First Nations hereditary leader loses court fight in LNG case
Court battle for Lelu Island dismissed for second time

Mr.Wesley  (Yahaan) has also faced some significant push back from other members of the Lax Kw'alaams Community, with a number of hereditary chiefs having stated that he should not be recognized as a representative of the Gitwilgyoots.

That dispute will  most likely continue to make for an element of the discussion, framing the backdrop to any plans the Lax Kw'alaams Band may have when it comes to resource development.

You can review the lengthy list of notes related to the now cancelled Pacific NorthWest LNG project from our archive here.

More items of note from our archive on Lax Kw'alaams can be reviewed here.


To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here.

Skeena MLA reminds Legislature of importance of Aquaculture in BC

Skeena MLA Ellis Ross spoke towards themes of the province's
Aquaculture industry this week in the Legislature
(photo from the BC Legislature video feed)

As we've noted over the course of the week, some of the Legislature's time for discussion during the four days of session work was focused on issues of the fishing industry, a topic for the most part covered extensively by North Coast MLA Jennifer Rice, who had two statements on the theme from Monday to Thursday.

Commercial fishing makes for theme of latest Fish Notes in Legislature from MLA Rice
Jennifer Rice brings fishery notes from weekend conference to Legislature Discussion

Another Northwest MLA also weighed in on the topic of the fishing industry, though as part of his discussion notes for the Legislature on Monday morning, Skeena MLA Ellis Ross reminded the House of the workings of the province's aquaculture industry.

As he noted for the Legislature, aquaculture is a source of employment for over 1,600 jobs in BC, many of them in rural and isolated communities that have traditionally faced high unemployment.

He further observed how the occupations associated with the aquaculture industry delivery salaries 30 percent higher than the median employment level of the province.

When it comes to a financial impact on BC, Mr. Ross noted that the industry provides for 1.1 billion dollars to the provincial economy as well as spin off activity for suppliers and the service industry.

With that kind of presence as part of the provincial economy, he called for the government to stop sending mixed signals on aquaculture, suggesting that at times the impression for many is that there is a threat to the industry in the province.

Some of the themes explored by the Skeena MLA focused on the support and partnership that the existing farms that are located on the Central Coast and points south have with First Nations

Because the industry is located along B.C.'s coastlines, salmon farmers rely on the support and partnership of the First Nations in whose traditional territory they operate. Currently B.C. salmon farmers are partnering with coastal First Nations on 20 economic and social partnerships. This has opened up many desperately needed employment opportunities for First Nations up and down the coast. 

 This motion calls for support for all agricultural sectors, including aquaculture. In a period of uncertainty with respect to NAFTA and our largest trading partner south of the border, products from B.C. farms are finding their ways into markets in Asia and beyond. That's why it's crucial that the fish farm industry receive support from all British Columbians, including the provincial government, because the fish farm industry has received mixed signals. 

On one hand, it seems to point to B.C.'s aquaculture industry as a threat, and in the same breath, as a dispute with Alberta and the federal government continues, there are claims that there are spokespeople working in the interest of saving jobs on the coast in regard to fish farms.

Mr. Ross also called on his experience as Chief Councillor of the Haisla to offer some observations on the need for balance when it comes to examining issues of aquaculture and wild fishing stocks.

I once served as a chief councillor of Haisla, and like many other First Nations, we were equally concerned with the health of wild salmon stocks. Even though there are no fish farms in the Douglas Channel in Haisla territory, we see inconsistent runs different years. The Skeena River sockeye has been declining too, again, with no fish farms in sight. So we have to ask ourselves a simple question: what is really affecting wild salmon? 

There are certain factors raised by scientists in the Cohen Commission and other credible reports that point to the real culprits. These include ocean warming, habitat damage and overfishing, including bycatch. 

 Everyone in this House wants to ensure that our wild salmon not only survive but thrive for the enjoyment of generations to come. But for this to happen, we need to focus on the real threats identified by science. In the meantime, let's provide our support for an industry that contributes to the overall health of our provincial economy and takes the pressure off our wild stocks.

You can review the full transcript of his commentary on the fishing sector from the Legislature Hansard from Monday Morning

You can also watch his presentation to the Chamber through the Legislature's Video Archive from the Monday morning session, the Skeena MLA stands to deliver his statement at the 11:20 mark.

More background on the Fishing industry on the North Coast can be found from our archive page.

For more items of note from Mr. Ross'w work in the Legislature see our archive page here, a larger overview of provincial issues can be found on our political blog D'Arcy McGee


To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here.

AltaGas Ridley project fabrication "on track" for service in first quarter of 2019

Topped Up on Ridley Island. AltaGas is celebrating the progress of their
Propane Gas Export Terminal on RidleyIsland, recently completing the
work on the roof of the storage tank at the facility

(image from AltaGas video)

Alta Gas, the Alberta based energy company that is building an export terminal on Ridley Island shared a status report this week as part of its 2017 Fourth quarter and year end results report released on Thursday.

The report which examined a range of items related to the energy company's business, put some of its focus on the progress of the Ridley Island  Propane Export Terminal, highlighting how the project is on track towards going into service early in 2019.

Construction of RIPET commenced during the second quarter of 2017 and is proceeding pursuant to an agreement with RILE LP. AltaGas is using its self-perform model that has been successfully used to execute its other projects on time and on budget. Crews have completed work on the concrete outer wall for the propane tank and the inner steel tank roof was installed at the end of January 2018. 

The balance of plant fabrication and civil work is on track and the first modules are scheduled to be installed in the first quarter of 2018. All long-lead equipment has been ordered with delivery schedules aligned with the construction schedule. RIPET is expected to be in-service in the first quarter of 2019.

The energy company also noted that work continues to add to further capacity commitments for product to be shipped out of the Prince Rupert terminal, with discussions currently underway with Astomos Energy and a number of other third party groups.

AltaGas LPG and Astomos Energy Corporation have entered into a multi-year agreement for the purchase of at least 50 percent of the 1.2 million tonnes per annum of propane expected to be available to be shipped from RIPET each year. Commercial discussions with Astomos and several third party off-takers for further capacity commitments are proceeding.

The complete report on the Prince Rupert project can be reviewed here.

In January the Ridley Island terminal celebrated it's roof raising with the following video posted to the Alta Gas website





As the storage facility begins to take shape, AltaGas is now turning its attention towards staffing levels for the Ridley Island terminal.

The company has introduced it's Operator Training program, providing the following video as part of its recruitment campaign for staffing requirements at the facility, the local training in Prince Rupert will be provided by Northwest Community College.




AltaGas will be hosting an information session for the program in Prince Rupert on Monday at NWCC, that event takes place from 6 to 8 PM.

Tuesday, the company will hold Interviews for admission to the training program, the interviews which take place from Noon until 8 P, will be scheduled as part of Monday's information session.


Similar sessions are planned for the Terrace area taking place on March 7 and 8.

In February, AltaGas hosted information and interview sessions for members of Metlakatla and Lax Kw'alaams.

Beyond the plans for the 14 operator positions at the terminal, once it is operational the total workforce for the facility is expected to number up to 50 permanent workers, with a range of
duties and positions to be available.

More background on the Ridley Island Propane Terminal can be reviewed on their website.

For more items of interest related to the LPG Terminal plans see our archive page here.


To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here.

RCMP to put focus on Distracted Driving through month of March

Northwest RCMP detachments will be paying extra attention
towards distracted driving this month

(photo from RCMP website)


If you are still engaged with your phone while driving, the time is here to break yourself free of a dangerous habit and one that as statistcs show, results in more than 25% of all crash fatalities and makes for the second leading case of fatal collisions in British Columbia.

RCMP members across Northwestern British Columbia will be stepping up their enforcement when it comes to Distracted Driving this month, and should you find yourself pulled over at the side of the road with a patrol car behind you, there's a good chance that your distractions will be a costly affair

The fines for distracted driving (using electronic device = 4 points or driving without due care = 6 points) start at $368 and 4 penalty points for a minimum of $543 for the first offence, and the costs go up even more with each subsequent offence. In addition, your insurance costs may be affected.

Distracted driving is more than just using an electronic device but also includes other distractions such as personal grooming, eating/drinking, reading, pets, other passengers and not knowing your route.

As part of their information campaign to raise awareness of the issue, the RCMP notes that doing any of these things while driving may cause your trip to end in tragedy.

You can find more background on the province wide effort from this information statement.

In the Northwest, the West Pacific Region Traffic Services unit also has a few reminders for motorists, with Terrace Inspector Sydney Lecky putting things into a pretty clear focus for us.

"If you get pulled over and receive a ticket, there is no one to be mad at but yourself . 

No call, email, text, etc. is worth putting your life and the life of others at risk. You have to leave your phone alone."

You can explore more of the Northwest themes on road safety here.

For more items related to the work of Emergency Service Responders on the North Coast see our archive page here.



To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here.

Commercial fishing makes for theme of latest Fish Notes in Legislature from MLA Rice

MLA Rice wrapped up the week the way she began it, speaking to themes
on the North Coast Fishing industry
(photo from BC Leg video feed)

It's been fish week at the Legislature, with North Coast MLA Jennifer Rice making use of some of her time for Statements to explore a couple of themes on the fishing industry on the North Coast.

As we outlined on Tuesday,  her first observations provided for a short overview of last week's Ecotrust Canada hosted conference on the impact of the fishery on coastal communities.

That event which was also attended by UFAWU-Unifor President and City Councillor Joy Thorkelson as well as Prince Rupert Mayor Lee Brain, featured a number of sessions and discussions on themes related to the fishery, as well as to look at the recently announced proposals for the  Federal Fishery Act.

Thursday morning, Ms. Rice turned her commentary towards the Commercial industry, with the MLA noting the importance of the industry in the social fabric that holds BC communities together, while providing some notes on the role of the commercial industry on the North Coast.

"In just one part of the province, the PNCIMA region, where my constituents and I live, are some of the most valuable fishing areas on Canada's Pacific coast. In 2010, the PNCIMA region yielded $415 million in wholesale value, just over half of the wild-caught marine fisheries wholesale value for the entire province.

There is more to fishing than profit margins. There are economic ripple effects, as fishermen spend money on equipment and supplies — fishing revenue spreading throughout the local businesses and local communities. Fishing also has a role in the gifting and trading of seafood, and commercial fishing vessels play a key role in this complex system. 

One fisherman may give or trade seafood to 100 other people. This food community contributes to food security in rural and remote communities. These days many fishermen are First Nations. Without the ability to commercial fish, they would not have the necessary vessels to exercise their food, social and ceremonial fishing rights and have the ability to feed elders and others in the community. 

Being a commercial fishermen is more than a job. It's a lifestyle that connects people to each other, to their communities and the surrounding environment."

As part of her commentary for the House, the North Coast MLA called attention to some of the work of Ecotrust Canada and the T. Buck Suzuki Environmental Foundation, noting how their work is providing for an opportunity to re-frame fisheries policy in Canada, with a view that will benefit environmental conservatism, economic resilience and social equality.

Her presentation to the Legislature can be reviewed below:


For more items of interest related to the Fishing industry on the North Coast see our archive page here.

A look at the work of the MLA in Victoria can be reviewed on our Legislature Archive page.

A wider overview of provincial issues can be found on our political blog D'Arcy McGee.


To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here.

Thursday, March 1, 2018

Council set to enhance role of Committee of the Whole Session with community group updates

How best to encourage participation in the Committee of the Whole proces
made for some discussion by Council on Monday evening.

Prince Rupert City Council will soon be sending out the invitations to those groups that receive funding from the city, offering community organizations an opportunity to provide an update on their work and a chance to showcase what they offer to community.

The community input program will be launched through the City Council Committee of the Whole process, which sees public comment opportunities offered up once a month.

As we noted on Monday, It's a community engagement initiative that has been proposed by Councillor Cunningham in the past and one he brought to the Council chamber on Monday evening as a motion for consideration.

Towards the end of the Monday session, Mr. Cunningham outlined the nature of the motion that he and Councillor Mirau have been working on, one which in its initial phase will be used to bring the list of Community Enhancement Grant recipients to council to provide for the updates.

"Councillor Mirau and I drafted this up together, we had some discussions about it and that, I think that it speaks for itself. The resolution is to bring funded societies, or organizations that we fund to Committee of the Whole to open it up for discussion. And I think it is something we should be doing so we can give transparency to the community. And let the community know what exactly is going on with these, I think it's a good start towards going down that road."

The original motion was included in the Agenda package for Monday's session.



As part of the discussion to the theme, Councillor Thorkelson offered up the suggestion that the proposal not be limited to just those groups that are funded by the City, but that it also include any group in the community which wishes to make a presentation to Council, with Ms. Thorkelson  looking to add that proposal to the concept of community engagement.

Council Thorkelson also suggested that the City should try to encourage organizations that are involved with community recreation to come and explain how they are working together to provide for recreation options in the community.

"I have been hoping for all my years on Council that we would get ... and maybe this is something that we could try to foster under resolutions such as this, to try to get organizations that are involved in recreation; the Curling Club, the Racquet Club , the Civic Centre, the Golf Course all to come at the same time and explain how they are working together to try to encourage sporting activities across the gamut of the services we are supporting.  

Recreation is only good if people take advantage of that, so to say what kind of coordination they are making between the different groups, I've been trying to encourage that, and I would hope maybe  that they could come at the same time and not only give a presentation on what their individual organizations are doing and how they are doing with recreation, but also how they are working together for the promotion of recreation in Prince Rupert"

That was a theme that Councillor Cunningham who is a member of the Recreation Commission echoed, noting that those groups could make use of the opportunity of that forum to better promote their programs.

On the topic of bringing in City Department heads to provide similar updates, Councillor Mirau outlined the nature of some of his hesitation towards using the COW process to include reports from those city officials, observing how he  fears that the city may be overstepping its bounds on governance.

One other aspect of Councillor Cunningham's motion is to also have the City's Fire/Rescue service and RCMP detachment provide regular updates to Council as part of the COW process.

The Mayor noted that when it comes to any reports from the RCMP or Fire Department that the main presentation would be limited to stats and notes of their work in the community and not operational aspects.

The speaking opportunities for community groups and other participants for 2018 however will be somewhat reduced from previous years.

With Council already into March now, that leaves room for but eight potential Council of the Whole sessions opportunities left on Council schedule for this year.

Back in December, City Council members voted to reduce their Public session workload for this year, included in that decision was the cancellation of any Public Council Sessions for the months of September and October.


You can review the discussion from Monday setting up the community engagement opportunity from the City's Video archive.  It starts at the thirty seven minute mark.




For more notes on Monday's City Council session see our Council Timeline Feature here, as well as from our Council Session Archive page. 

Further background on City Council discussion topics can be reviewed from our Council Discussion archive.

To return to the most recent blog posting of the day, click here.