Wednesday, July 6, 2022

BC Liberals of the North Coast find much to like from Prince Rupert Mayor's State of the City address



Some of the reaction to Mayor Lee Brain's State of the City presentation of last week has delivered some high profile support over the last seven days; starting with the Mayor of Port Edward Knut Bjorndal who joined the Mayor on Stage on June 28th to celebrate a new relationship with Prince Rupert, following up on social media with some thoughts on the night.


Likewise, the Prince Rupert Chamber of Commerce also left the Lester Centre with good memories from the event, vowing to work to bring Mayor Brain's vision plan to the finish line as he departs office.


But perhaps the most enthusiastic review of the Mayor's presentation came from the North Coast BC Liberal Party Riding Association, which used his talking points and observations for some political message making on the provincial front last week.


Those among the BC Liberals of the region, no doubt were listening with much interest as the Mayor recounted his battles with the Province towards the issue of the Port Property Tax Act and the frustration that he and council has found from the province when it comes to addressing civic issues.  

Though the local Liberals may have tuned out the part where the Mayor said the issue dates back as much to his early days of office, the dispute one which has continued since the NDP government took office.

"I'll tell you how much effort I put into this file, I'll tell ya. I organized every single community that had the same impact, all the Mayors down south. We lobbied both the BC Liberals and BC NDP. 

We did song and dance, I put pom poms on. 

Like we did everything and they haven't moved on that. And there's some reasons I probably shouldn't say it publicly. But this challenge, the Port Property Tax Act is the number one reason why this community is stuck, we are stuck, we are not allowed to be free"

The early portion of the time of that lobbying campaign of course was during the reign of the BC Liberals as led by then Premier Christy Clark; who didn't appear to move much either towards accommodating the City in their time of need at the time.

Still, the Local riding association members do have a bit of a narrative to share, when pointing out that the Prince Rupert area hasn't really benefited much from NDP attention since they took on the powers of government. 

Yes a few initiatives have been delivered to the city mainly in social housing areas and including some funding for a few of the Mayor's vision planning items from Hays 2.0 and the Rupert Vision 2030 program.

But there is so much more that needs to be done that hasn't been and at times there does seem to be a feeling that NDP Party officials take the North Coast as a given on Election Day and area that doesn't require much to keep the voting base happy.

The local Liberals may have also missed the moment when Mr. Brain did offer up some sympathy to the political burdens for Ms. Rice on Presentation night. 

Noting that she was onboard with the City's fight on many issues and that she has her own challenges within her own party, some inside baseball from the mayor that maybe the MLA herself may want to expand upon with the voters one day perhaps.

"Who, by the way Jen, I'm so sorry, she is  a very big supporter of us.  

She works really hard with us, works with our staff. I know I crapped on the caps, she's very much helping with the caps, disclaimer.

Ok, cause yeah I would feel awkward if I was sitting in a presentation. And, just so you know she's actually helping us with that and she has her challenges in her own government and stuff."

Even though the Mayor gave no indication as to his future come October, the attention given to the Mayor's presentation by the local Liberals does seem a bit like they may have put out the Bat Signal for him perhaps to consider a new direction for his political life.   

Maybe even as a candidate under the BC Liberal banner, or whatever new name that they may come up with in the next few months following the current review put forward by recently elected leader Kevin Falcon.

It would make for an interesting bit of matchmaking, the Mayor who clearly is a believer in heavy provincial funding for civic governments; signing on with a free enterprise party that may not be as inclined as the local group suggests when it comes towards funnelling large amounts of cash to municipalities and funding ambitious vision plans.

Not to mention his part in the evolution of a few new municipally operated instruments in both Watson Island and Legacy Corporation, not to mention the continued ownership of CityWest.

Most of which would seem to run against the free enterprise spirit of the BC Liberal party.

As well, there is a range of environmental and sustainability themes from the Mayor over the last eight years and before even his entry into local politics, areas which  would seem to make him more aligned with the NDP,  or even the Greens, over the Liberals. 

Particularly of note in areas of LNG say, something which remains a major platform for the BC Liberals, and and  area where Prince Rupert City Council has seen a number of high profile local projects fade away.

The prospect of Mr. Brain taking on the challenge  for a seat in Victoria however, would certainly create some interest in the election campaign when it comes around (maybe sooner than thought depending on how the NDP leadership race plays out this fall)

The last time a former Prince Rupert Mayor took on the NDP on the North Coast was during the 2017 provincial election when Herb Pond, took the challenge to Jennifer Rice

A contest which saw the NDP MLA returned to office with a larger vote margin than the 2013 election, when the Liberals had sent Judy Fraser into battle.


That 2017 campaign, was the second time that Mr. Pond had sought out a seat in the Legislature, having taken on incumbent Gary Coons in the 2009 campaign.

In that contest, Mr. Pond, claimed 3,110 votes in a three way race, which saw Gary Coons come out of the vote count as the victor. Lisa Gribav the Green candidate of the day claiming third sport.

Then like today, the main theme was that the region needed an advocate that could bring funding and other benefits from the province to the region.

Should they put out the welcome mat for Mr. Brain, the BC Liberals would clearly be using much the same script as has been in place for close to twelve years. A period of time that has continued to send NDP representatives back to the Legislature.

Perhaps the prospect of a campaign of former municipal politicians, Ms, Rice was once a city councillor, might help to spur on some voter participation. 

The volume of North Coast voters from recent elections of any stripe, one which doesn't require anyone around to keep the doors clear at the voting stations.

And who know, perhaps Ms. Rice may have other plans in mind and take leave of the provincial scene. 

Though her recent comments following the announcement of the Premier's decision to step down, seem to indicate she's still part of the NDP Team in Victoria that will carry the fight forward.


Whether a candidate with even as high a profile and a long cultivated popularity among a portion of the community, as the current Prince Rupert Mayor enjoys, can cut into hold that the NDP has on the region would be an interesting question.  

Something that the BC Liberals will have to weigh carefully as they look for just the right candidate to try to topple an NDP Machine locally that is always up for a good political scrap.

More notes on the provincial scene can be explored through our Legislature archive page

3 comments:

  1. North Coast BC LiberalsJuly 6, 2022 at 12:20 PM

    I wouldn't say that we found much to like in the Mayor's presentation. More than anything I'd suggest that we found it concerning. Just a few years ago our municipal infrastructure deficit was pegged at around $300 million and, despite Watson Island contributing to the tax roll once again and projects like the Woodworth Dam replacement nearing completion, our deficit has has increased by more than a quarter of a billion dollars. That's a lot for this small community to bear. As far as Prince Rupert has come, there's undoubtedly a lot more work to be done to get the community repaired and in a financially healthy state.

    That should include a review and possible amendments to the Port Property Tax Act, at least in how it relates to Prince Rupert. The legislation was put into place in 2004 to make investment attractive and our community has benefitted from it in many ways. In 2004, the pulp mill had just closed and our industrial base was hurting. Many had to leave town to find work, property values fell into the basement and an increased tax burden fell onto the shoulders of residential and small business tax payers. Since then we've seen port growth in terms of the container port, Pinnacle Pellet, Alta Gas, and Ray Mont, for example. We've also seen other industries/proponents such as Canpotex, BG Group, Westpac and PNW LNG take a long look at doing business here before moving on for various reasons. Of course, Vopak is still exploring the possibility of developing on Ridley Island as well.

    However, despite the Port Property Tax Act helping to encourage development, creating jobs and opportunity, and redefining our local economy, it appears that the legislation restricts the City of Prince Rupert's ability to generate the revenue needed to manage its needs. Prince Rupert's advantage is it's position as a port and the community needs to maximize its benefit. Our leader, Kevin Falcon, has always been a strong supporter of the north coast and helped bring the container port to Prince Rupert as Minister of Transportation. We will be bringing our local perspective to him so that further discussions can be had at a higher level.

    We also need to touch on what we believe is a need to have a stronger voice for Prince Rupert in Victoria. Despite the ongoing financial issues that the City of Prince Rupert has had for the past two decades, when has anyone seen our MLA publicly support a proponent of a development? We've seen her in Council Chambers with a group of activists fighting against a project but we've yet to see her stand up and and help bring a proposed development to a positive final investment decision. In fact, we'd suggest that any economic progress in the community is in spite of our MLA, not because of her.

    A $300 million infrastructure deficit that's ballooned to a $600 million infrastructure deficit in 5 years deserves more attention and support from our provincial representative to help secure new sources of revenue. The members of this community deserve no less.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Escalate this to Victoria while you are at it,

      Why has the province refused to distribute cannabis taxes to municipalities?

      https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/b-c-has-received-more-than-112m-in-excise-cannabis-taxes-none-has-gone-to-municipalities-1.6489904

      These taxes would help communities like Prince Rupert add resources to expedite bylaw changes and proactively enforce those bylaw changes to ensure local medicinal cannabis production is compliant and safe.

      Delete
  2. Keep the PPTA the way it is, you open it and every other port city will want to tweak it.
    Which will push our local interests to the back of the line behind the likes of Vancouver, Surrey and Delta.

    Lobby to increase the PILT as an offset (5 year top up, with a sunset), during that time help Prince Rupert fund/attract investment in the Major industry or Light business verticals, the tax rates the city can control.

    Prince Rupert needs to fill its economic pipeline with opportunities to service and compliment the Port.


    ReplyDelete